Rethinking Sustainable Choices: The Paper Straw and Bag Predicament

In our class session with Dalkia EDF, our discussions about sustainable solutions geared toward tackling climate change got me thinking. It seems that big corporations and governments are rushing into climate change solutions without really checking how well they work in practice. This haste often results in poorly designed products meant to be eco-friendly alternatives. I believe true sustainability should look beyond just being eco-friendly and also consider how practical and user-friendly these choices are.

In recent years, we’ve witnessed a surge in environmental sustainability efforts, especially in reducing plastic waste. One of the visible outcomes of this movement is the adoption of paper straws and paper bags as eco-friendly alternatives. While the intention is certainly good, it’s essential to examine whether these changes are genuinely usable and practical and if they contribute to a sustainable future.

The ongoing movement to ban plastic bags and straws are usually based on the reasons that these items are made from nonrenewable resources, they don’t break down safely, and they pose a serious threat to our planet. While the alternatives, paper bags and paper straws are made from renewable resources, they are biodegradable, and they are not a health hazard to animals and the ecosystem at large. While the push for sustainability is undoubtedly a step in the right direction, it is equally important to evaluate the practicality and usability of eco-friendly alternatives, such as paper straws and bags. Usability boils down to how well a product works and how easy it is to use, while practicality assesses how effectively it performs in real-life situations.

Paper Straws: An Uncomfortable Alternative

One of the notable drawbacks of paper straws lies in their user experience. Several factors contribute to the discomfort associated with paper straws. First and foremost is their dissolvability. When exposed to liquid for an extended period, paper straws tend to dissolve, resulting in a mushy and unpleasant texture in your mouth, which can be quite uncomfortable. Secondly, as paper straws absorb liquid, they become soft and soggy, making them less sturdy and harder to use. This sogginess can result in a compromised drinking experience, making it frustratingly difficult to enjoy your drink without interruptions caused by bending or collapse. Additionally, some users find that paper straws impart an unusual taste to their drinks, which can be off-putting. This taste can be described as “paper-like” or “cardboard-like,” which is not what people expect when enjoying a beverage. Moreover, the texture of paper straws against the lips and tongue can be uncomfortable for some users, as it lacks the smoothness of plastic straws. Lastly, users also frequently grapple with inserting a paper straw into the small hole or opening on the top of juice packs. This task proves to be a daunting challenge as the tip of the straw keeps bending, and the more one tries, the worse the issue becomes, which can be frustrating and bothersome. While the design of paper straws aims to be an environmentally friendly choice, they do come with layers of inherent discomfort that challenge their usability.

The ironic twist about paper straw is that it often comes with a drink in a plastic cup with a plastic lid. In essence, this situation raises questions about the authenticity of sustainability efforts. It prompts individuals to reflect on whether the implementation of eco-friendly alternatives is genuinely aimed at solving environmental problems or if it’s merely a form of greenwashing—a facade that feigns eco-consciousness without meaningful change. Like seriously, what’s the point of a paper straw in a plastic cup? This situation can make people feel frustrated and even angry. They thought they were doing the right thing, but it seemed like their efforts were pointless. It makes them wonder if we’re solving the problem or pretending to be environmentally friendly.

Paper Bags: Not the Best for Carrying Stuff

The adoption of paper bags as an eco-friendly alternative to plastic bags has gained momentum in recent years. However, it’s crucial to acknowledge that paper bags bring their share of discomfort to the table. Firstly, paper bags are generally less durable and may tear or rip easily, especially if they are overloaded or exposed to moisture. This lack of durability can be a source of frustration when carrying a lot of items. Also, some paper bags lack handles, making them less ergonomic for carrying heavy or numerous items. Users often need to use both hands to prevent the bag from slipping or tearing. Moreover, paper bags’ vulnerability to moisture is a well-known issue, rendering them unsuitable for transporting groceries in rainy weather or carrying items with liquids. Lastly, paper bags often have a long, narrow shape that may not provide the flexibility for carrying certain items. Items forced into it may easily tear the bag. These discomforts remind us that while paper bags serve a noble purpose in reducing plastic waste, their practical inconveniences should be considered when making sustainable choices.

One of the great ironies surrounding the use of paper bags and straws lies in the killing of trees to make them. The raw materials required for these eco-friendly alternatives come from trees, a natural resource that is otherwise carbon-fixing. This raises a compelling question: Are we making the best use of our trees, which play a crucial role in absorbing carbon dioxide and releasing life-sustaining oxygen? Making paper bags and straws is synonymous with killing one of our greatest tools for fighting pollution. I believe trees have more important purposes than just being used as paper bags and straws.

The Bigger Issue: Human Behavior

The central problem isn’t with straws or bags; it’s with waste management. Plastic straws and bags are recyclable, and it’s our responsibility to dispose of them correctly. Proper disposal and recycling practices can prevent these items from ending up in the ocean and ensure they get a new life as recycled products. However, in our modern world, it’s often easier for governments and larger corporations to jump on the “BAN THEM” bandwagon rather than tackle the root issue.

Designing for User-Friendly Sustainability

From a design perspective, user experience and convenience are paramount. The challenges people encounter with paper straws and bags highlight the need for more thoughtful design in sustainable solutions. Going green shouldn’t mean compromising usability. Designers should prioritize accessibility and functionality when creating eco-friendly alternatives. In conclusion, while the push for sustainability is indeed a step in the right direction, it’s equally crucial to assess the practicality and usability of eco-friendly choices like paper straws and bags. True sustainability goes beyond just being environmentally friendly; it should also make our lives easier and more efficient while respecting our planet.

‍

References

Lidwell, W. “Universal Principles of Design/William Lidwell, Kritina Holden, Jill Butler.” Beverly, Mass.: Rockport Publishers (2010).

UN Climate Change

Dalkia EDF